Schedule a Consult

So, How Do You Actually Decide What’s Reasonable for Yourself in a World Obsessed with Diets?

anti-diet end weight stigma haes mental health therapy values focused windoverwatercounseling windwaterwellness Jan 06, 2025

Ah, diet culture—the sneaky goblin hiding under the guise of “self-improvement” and “health,” armed with its “life-changing” detox teas and suspiciously beige meal prep boxes. The gift that keeps on guilt tripping. Our society’s favorite fix-it tool for all that ails us, wrapped in a glossy package of “before and after” photos, fad diets, and a million ways to feel guilty about eating a cookie. It’s that constant, nagging voice whispering, “But what if you could just… lose a little weight?” 

And every January (or, let’s be real, every Monday), it bursts onto the scene like an uninvited guest at brunch, demanding we trade pancakes for shame and joy for diet food. Like that annoying friend who’s always “just trying to help,” but their idea of help involves shaming your body, your food choices, and your very existence. 

And boy, does it know how to multitask: fads, “healthy” tips, and all the unsolicited advice about what you should be eating (or not eating). The world always seems to scream at us to be leaner, cleaner, and “healthier” in the most exhausting ways possible. And just in case you’re already deep in “New Year, New Me” talk, let’s be clear: You don’t need to punish yourself to live a full, happy, or healthy life.

Guess what? You’re allowed to ignore that voice. Not only is diet culture exhausting, but it’s also a con artist, promising happiness and delivering guilt. It’s sneaky, like a “wellness tip” from a well-meaning friend or relative, or the gnawing guilt after we eat “bad” foods or even just the (culturally conditioned and incredibly powerful) belief that we’d be more worthy, lovable, or successful if only we dropped a few pounds. So how do you figure out what’s reasonable, healthy, and actually good for you in this chaos? How do you find what actually works for you, without bowing to the demands of diet culture?

You don’t need to suffer through diet food you don’t enjoy or dangerous/unfun marathon workouts to be worthy of love, respect, or a fulfilling life. Let’s talk about how to tune out the noise and decide what’s actually reasonable for you. Warning: It involves ignoring diet culture’s sneaky nonsense and embracing the radical idea that you’re already enough.

Let’s roll up our sleeves and kick diet culture out of the party with a HAES (Health at Every Size) aligned anti-diet framework to make peace with food and your body.

What Do You Actually Want?

Here’s a plot twist: Your goals don’t have to align with a random influencer’s meal plan or your coworker’s latest juice cleanse. You can opt out of the misery Olympics and decide what matters to you. 

Sounds simple, right? But diet culture thrives on telling us what we should want (thinness, “cleanness,” control) instead of encouraging us to actually listen to our bodies. One of the most powerful ways to push back against this is by clarifying what you actually want from your relationship with food and health.

Want more energy to run around with your kids or dance like no one’s watching? Want a balanced relationship with food where you can eat pasta without the guilt trip or a calorie count? Great. Your desires are yours, not a template from some influencer’s #WhatIEatInADay post. Let’s honor what you need, not what diet culture whispers in your ear like a passive-aggressive frenemy. Those goals are yours, and they’re valid. Your body, your rules.

Redefine “Healthy”—No, Really - Consider What “Healthy” Truly Means

Diet culture has tried to monopolize “healthy,” reducing it to salads and burpees. But let’s get real: health is about so much more. Physical health matters, sure, but so do your emotional, social, and mental health.

Emotional well-being? Healthy. Building friendships? Healthy. Laughing until you cry over your dog’s weird sneeze? Definitely healthy.

Real health doesn’t require you to feel miserable. Health isn’t deprivation or dread. If a wellness plan leaves you obsessed, exhausted, or unable to enjoy cake at your own birthday party, it’s not healthy—it’s a red flag. True health doesn’t demand perfection; it embraces balance. Eat the veggies and the dessert. Walk when it feels good - or move your body in other ways that feel good—whether that’s yoga, boxing, gardening, sitting, or dancing to 90s pop. Take time to do things that refresh and renew you - not just the things that you think you’re supposed to do. 

A healthy approach to food and movement should support all aspects of you. Remember, joyful movement and nutritious, delicious foods are valid options—but so are rest days and comfort foods. And you can’t forget social connection, laughter, finding your passions, and having fun. Health is a long game and a balancing act, not a quick fix.

Remember: Healthy isn’t about what you restrict; it’s about what you nourish—body, mind, and soul. Healthy” doesn’t mean punishing yourself—it’s about taking care of yourself. Health is a lifelong pursuit.

Hunger is a Signal, NOT a Moral Failing

Diet culture says hunger is the enemy. It would have you believe that hunger is some sort of personal preference. Oh, you’re hungry?  Drink water, chew gum, light a candle—anything but eat! 

Let’s flip the script. Hunger is your body’s way of saying, “Hey, fuel me!” It’s not a test of willpower; it’s a biological signal. Trusting your body to know when it needs food is part of intuitive eating. It’s scary at first if you’ve spent years dieting, but wow, is it freeing. If you’re hungry, you’re allowed to eat. That’s not “weakness,” it’s human biology.

Listening to hunger and fullness cues is part of intuitive eating, a practice that trusts your body knows what it needs. Tuning into hunger and fullness is radical in a world obsessed with restriction. Relearning to trust those cues after years of diet rules can feel strange, but it’s worth it. Hunger isn’t the enemy; guilt is. Here’s your permission slip: If you’re hungry, eat. Not because I said so, but because your body deserves to be fed. Radical, I know. 

Practicing this takes time, especially if years of dieting have turned hunger into something “bad.” But reclaiming that inner trust? That’s freedom. HAES encourages us to honor these signals, helping us eat in a way that’s satisfying and sustaining.

Mindful Prompt: “What would happen if I honored/trusted my hunger today without judgment or second-guessing?”

Evaluate “Wellness” Goals with a Filter for Diet Culture’s Sneakiness

“Wellness” is diet culture’s rebrand, complete with essential oil pyramids and $10 green juices—same guilt, but it often smuggles in the same toxic messages but in prettier packaging. If a wellness goal feels more like a trap than freedom, it might just be diet culture in disguise.

*side note - I know I put “wellness” in the name of my business - but that’s because wellness is, and can be, a good thing. You do not have to let diet culture and corporate marketing hijack it - you can define your own wellness. 

Ask yourself: Is this goal truly about feeling good? Or is it another way to squeeze into society’s narrow definition of “worthy”? Real wellness comes without a side of obsession. So when the latest detox tea or “biohacking” advice shows up, ask: “Does this actually make me feel good, or is it just diet culture wearing yoga pants?” Real wellness should nourish, not deplete, you. If your wellness pursuit leaves you stressed, restricted, or obsessed, it might just be diet culture with a new face.

Key Questions: “Does this make me feel alive, or does it just make me tired?” “Is this about feeling good, or shrinking myself?”“Is this wellness goal about feeling good or looking a certain way?”

Be critical. Scrutinize these wellness trends and detox plans. Real wellness is about what feels nourishing and enjoyable for you, not about squeezing yourself into a tiny, exhausting box of restriction.

Try Neutralizing Food Drama (Yes, Even with Carbs)

Diet culture divides food into “good” and “bad,” “clean” and “junk,” but let’s be honest—food is just food. Morality has no place on your plate. Practicing food neutrality means seeing all foods as valid, no matter what it is. When we let go of guilt, we’re able to enjoy the foods we love without the baggage. It’s not clean or dirty. It’s not a moral compass, failing, or morality of any sort. Practicing food neutrality means ditching the labels and just letting food be food.

Here’s the magic: when you take foods off their “forbidden” pedestal, they lose that obsessive hold. Carbs are not evil, desserts are not “guilty pleasures”—they’re just different foods that play different roles. Removing judgment from food is a powerful way to reclaim control from diet culture.

Mantra: “Food is not my enemy, and my plate doesn’t define my worth. All foods fit. I am allowed to enjoy food without guilt.  I am allowed to enjoy the full range of foods.”

Let’s say it louder for the people in the back: Food has no moral value. Carbs aren’t villains, and cake isn’t a “guilty pleasure”—it’s just cake. It becomes less of an emotional battleground and more of a normal, satisfying experience. You deserve to enjoy your meals without a side of shame. 

Food isn’t good or bad. When you stop moralizing food, you stop obsessing over it. 

HAES: The Respect Your Body Deserves 

Health at Every Size (HAES®) is a framework that says, “Hey, health isn’t about weight; it’s about behaviors that support well-being.” It’s about self-care, not self-punishment. It’s about respecting your body now, not waiting until you’ve lost X pounds. The HAES® approach is revolutionary because it emphasizes that health and body size are not synonymous. It prioritizes your well-being over the size of your jeans. It says, “Let’s focus on behaviors that nourish you, not shrink you.” Movement, rest, eating, joy—they’re all valid paths to health. The scale? Not invited to this party. 

Diet culture loves to equate health with weight loss, but HAES shows us a better way: nurture your body as it is. Because you can’t hate/shame yourself into health, but you can care for yourself into well-being.

Body respect means treating yourself like you’re already worthy of care—because spoiler alert: you are. Right here, right now.

Body respect isn’t always easy in a culture that glorifies thinness. Respecting your body as it is allows for sustainable, compassionate choices instead of the restrictive (and often impossible) standards set by diet culture.

HAES® has been around for over a decade and has an awesome Health Sheet Library that details different medical concerns and how they interact with weight stigma and the HAES® approach.  

Boundaries, Please

Picture this: You’re at brunch, enjoying your time to socialize and eat something someone else made and will clean up, when someone starts waxing poetic about their diet saga/journey. Do you:
A) Smile and nod while screaming internally?
B) Excuse yourself to go pet a dog?
C) Kindly set a boundary?

You don’t have to engage- you can set boundaries around diet talk. It doesn’t need to take up space in your head or your conversations. Politely redirect or set firm boundaries—it’s self-preservation. Try, “I’m focusing on a positive relationship with food, so I’d rather not discuss diets.” Or, “Can we talk about something else?” Boundaries aren’t mean or rude; they’re self-care. Protect your peace.

We’ve all been at a dinner where someone brings up their latest diet, or a friend proudly declares they’re “being so good” by skipping dessert. Let me be clear: You do not have to participate. You are allowed to set boundaries around diet talk and redirect conversations. There’s no shame in politely letting someone know you’re not interested in discussing diets or body critique.

You do not have to set a boundary. But depending on where you are in your awareness journey, you might need to. Once you start seeing all the diet and productivity culture messaging and how it interacts with systems of oppression, you won’t be able to stop seeing it. 

Be Compassionate with Yourself Along the Journey

Undoing diet culture’s hold is a process, not a one-time decision. There will be days when you feel fantastic about your choices, and days when old diet thoughts sneak back in. That’s okay! Be gentle with yourself and remember that every step toward self-compassion is a win.

Instead of aiming for perfection, aim for progress. Celebrate each moment you honor your hunger, each time you reject the pressure to conform to diet culture’s rules, each instance you choose joy over restriction.

This isn’t a one-and-done deal. Breaking free from diet culture is a winding path, not a straight road. Some days you’ll nail it; others, you might fall into old patterns. That’s okay. Progress isn’t about being perfect; it’s about showing up for yourself with kindness.

Celebrate the wins, no matter how small. Honor your hunger. Eat the cake. Set the boundary. Each choice is a step toward reclaiming your joy and your life from diet culture’s grasp. Some days, you’ll feel like a rockstar; other days, diet culture will sneak back in. That’s okay. You’re doing the work, and that’s enough.

---

So the next time diet culture sneaks in with a shiny promise of transformation, remember: You don’t need to sacrifice your joy, your peace, or your respect for your body to live a full and healthy life. Embrace the messiness of figuring out what works for you, not what society says you should do.

And if you ever forget, here’s your reminder: You are enough—exactly as you are, right now. Diet culture doesn’t stand a chance against your newfound awareness.

 

Resources and Links:

Famous Quotes:

  • “You don’t have to be perfect to be amazing.” – Unknown
  • “Our bodies are our gardens, to which our wills are gardeners.” – William Shakespeare
  • “To love oneself is the beginning of a lifelong romance.” – Oscar Wilde
  • “The moment you accept yourself, you become beautiful.” —Osho
  • “Your body hears everything your mind says.” —Naomi Judd
  • “Self-care is not self-indulgence. It is self-respect.” —Audre Lorde
  • “Health is not about the weight you lose, but the life you gain.” —Unknown

Affirmations & Reminders:

  • “I deserve to pursue health and joy in a way that honors my needs, not society’s checklist.”
  • “I deserve to pursue health and well-being in a way that’s meaningful and realistic for me.”
  • “I deserve to pursue joy in ways that feel meaningful to me.”
  • “My body is my home, and it deserves love and care just as it is. My body is worthy of care, just as it is today.”   
  • “My body is worthy of care and respect, just as it is today.”
  • “I’m allowed to disengage from conversations that don’t serve me.”
  • “I am more than a number on a scale.”
  • “I listen to my body’s needs with kindness.”
  • “I choose freedom over restriction.”
  • “I am worthy of care, compassion, and freedom—just as I am.”
  • “I am allowed to set boundaries to support my mental health.”
  • “My relationship with food is my own, and I’m allowed to protect it.”
  • “I am learning and growing at my own pace.”  
  • “I am learning, growing, and reclaiming my relationship with my body and food—one step at a time.”